Now, while I'm not a fan of Takashi Miike, this movie is very good. However it's not as good as a David Lynch film. It was similar, with distorted internal logic and surreal things happening with no indication that they haven't happened. But it falls victim again to Miike's “LOOK GUYS, LOOK HOW SUBTLE I'M BEING.”
Watching this with Maher and Chloe, they immediately were all over this movie's obvious subtlety, saying it was a giant thematic metaphor of birth and gender identity and all of these other things that are pretty easy to find after the fact. However what was on the screen was a Lynchian simple story accented by weirdness.
I absolutely despise scrutinizing a movie in an attempt to dredge philosophy out of it. Just because an event on the screen does not follow real world or even internal logic does not mean that you can write is off saying, “That didn't really happen, it was a metaphor.” This is a cop out. Also you can't criticize a film the same way you can a piece of literature. They are drastically different mediums, and while Stu tells me that this does not need to be said, I have found that an unreasonable amount of people seem to think this is the correct course of action.
Now, don't get me wrong. I liked this movie very much, and would recommend it. I just wouldn't recommend watching it with someone who thinks Miike is the best filmmaker in history, because he is far from it.
Recommendations:
The Exterminating Angel
Twin Peaks
Showing posts with label surreal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label surreal. Show all posts
Thursday, August 14, 2008
The American Astronaut
This movie would be the perfect double feature with Forbidden Zone. It was described to me as “a space-opera western” and that's just about how it is. A renegade spacer tries to collect a reward through a series of very silly trades. My only complaint was the end seemed a little loose. I would have gladly watched another hour of this movie if they wanted to wrap it up better. Still, that was not enough to make me dislike it in any way. Score!
Recommendations:
Forbidden Zone
Recommendations:
Forbidden Zone
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
